kylef
Gone
+1,352|6711|N. Ireland
Completel unorthodox to my previous thread, but I'll add it in anyway. Let people (constructively) criticize it but if you don't like it, well that's just your style!

Okay here's the jig;

A lot of people don't enter the SOTW, or don't post their art, because they think it sucks. Well listen to me, it doesn't suck. Everyone has their own style of art! Story, just to show you:

- I had to do art for 3 years. I thought my art was great. I solely used lines that I wanted to use, paid no attention to detail and made it look like a sort of authentic theme. Many agreed that it did look good, I really liked some of it too;

- My art teacher on the other hand, disagreed. She said (in a polite fashion), that it sucked. This scarred me from ever doing art again.

But the point is, even though my art teacher is wrong, I can't tell her that otherwise I'd get in some serious trouble. But this is a forum, you aren't face to face, you aren't going to get in trouble (assuming you don't take it too far). So please! Post your art and let people constructively criticize it! Try it, but if you don't like it, that's just your style then! Don't be discouraged because some people's art is "better", your art rocks too. It's just not many people think the same way.
So go for it, post your art and have it rated! I don't have any on hand, so the next person who gets their art posted is the first one heh.
psH
Banned
+217|6601|Sydney
https://img156.imageshack.us/img156/9076/tachikomasigsx2.jpg
by the way, that pic is a tachikoma from ghost in the shell anime.
yeah good idea kyle. (the thread)

Last edited by Doms (2007-05-20 02:06:29)

OmniDeath
~
+726|6861

4/10
poor composition, poor contrast, and i cant tell what it is.


and is this thread necessary? there are at least three other "post your art here" threads.
kylef
Gone
+1,352|6711|N. Ireland

OmniDeath wrote:

4/10
poor composition, poor contrast, and i cant tell what it is.


and is this thread necessary? there are at least three other "post your art here" threads.
i couldn't find 1.. direct me? i saw a 'rate my sig' a 'graphics requests' etc but none of this..
OmniDeath
~
+726|6861

All of these are "post your art" threads...

http://forums.bf2s.com/viewtopic.php?id=44429
http://forums.bf2s.com/viewtopic.php?id=72452
http://forums.bf2s.com/viewtopic.php?id=71171
http://forums.bf2s.com/viewtopic.php?id=69085

While you may argue that they don't all call for a rating to be given, some of them do request feedback, and in most cases people do give feedback, both good and bad, to the posted work. Besides, first post in and this is almost a "rate the sig above" repeat.

Last edited by OmniDeath (2007-05-20 02:39:06)

kylef
Gone
+1,352|6711|N. Ireland
'show off' 'your best' isn't exactly rating.. this is a specific rate thread, not just people saying "it's good" - real advice should be given.
OmniDeath
~
+726|6861

leetkyle wrote:

'show off' 'your best' isn't exactly rating.. this is a specific rate thread, not just people saying "it's good" - real advice should be given.
real advice? real advice isnt given in any of the "rate the above" threads. only a number on a scale of one to ten. i wouldnt exactly want my "art" rated in such a manner with out proper reasoning given...

anyway, i was only saying. it seems every other day a new "post your art here" thread pops up, and while this calls for a rating, its really not that different (at least in those people give feedback beyond a number rating).

but whatever...

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2024 Jeff Minard