Good thread. I just picked up 1942 (haven't played it yet) cause it came with Medal of Honor Allied Assault and Secret Weapons over Normandy all for 9.99, so I couldn't resist (although I hated SW for xbox thanks to the controls...).
BFV, I loved it ... still do. I think its the best in the series. The use of cover, the meaty explosions and the variation in kit types, it has it all. BFV for the win
Edit: Yeah, great thread ... been thinking about this for a while +1 for you