uziq wrote:
Jay wrote:
Putting a critic in charge of each agency might actually do some good. There's enough inertia that prevents radical changes.
it's not a critic, it's a non-expert. there's a big difference. it's part of the populist backlash against 'experts' and technocrats. i can agree with it to a degree, when government and politics has become so specialised and mandarin, for a certain 'caste' of society only to engage in ... but this goes too far the other way. it's philistine and anti-intellectual.
also i feel like most people don't really care about the size of their bank accounts. it's the weird ideological assumption that you sometimes find wherein people think 'financial success' = 'must have aptitude'. we really need to do away with the idea that a successful banker or a person with 'real business experience' is somehow intrinsically good at leadership or politics. it's a spurious assumption. people born into enormous wealth or privilege don't have to do much – other than not fuck up tremendously – to do well in life. trump is a walking advertisement of this. i think people are wary of this idea that a staff full of billionaires is going to be a staff of hard pragmatists who know who to broker deals and 'just get it done'.
I've met too many completely incompetent rich people to equate wealth with skill. Maybe when I was younger and more idealistic, but man, if you heard the dumb crap the bankers on my train talk about every day, a lot of them are worse than the union grunts...
Anyway, like I said, there's enough inertia built into government service that it's nearly impossible for any administration to elicit change. They literally have jobs for life and it takes an act of congress to remove them. They'll sit back, ignore what they can get away with, and keep on doing what they've been doing until the next administration rolls into town.
The people at the top don't need to be experts, they just need to have enough energy to call the bureaucrats out on their shit and reign them in as much as they can.
Last edited by Jay (2016-12-20 16:19:14)