Music Formatting Question

2011-02-27 13:12:11

#1

Microwave: _; +515|6870|Loughborough Uni / Leeds, UK

If I have a song with a 'featuring' does it go in the artist or the song field?

eg:

Eminem Ft. Lil Wayne - No Love

OR

Eminem - No Love Ft Lil Wayne

My music library needs this clarification to keep it uniform!

2011-02-27 13:15:46

#2

Sisco: grandmaster league revivalist; +493|6558

not sure if serious...

i votet artist btw

Last edited by Sisco (2011-02-27 13:16:03)

https://www.abload.de/img/bf3-bf2ssig0250wvn.jpg

2011-02-27 13:16:39

#3

Microwave: _; +515|6870|Loughborough Uni / Leeds, UK

100% serious.

My library needs to take one turn, it can't be a mix of both!

Last edited by Microwave (2011-02-27 13:19:09)

2011-02-27 13:16:41

#4

PrivateVendetta: I DEMAND XMAS THEME; +704|6406|Roma

Always title.
I hate having loads of different categories when searching for all songs by a certain artist on my iPod. Barely ever search for songs by the featured artist and want a song they featured in..

Last edited by PrivateVendetta (2011-02-27 13:17:26)

https://static.bf2s.com/files/user/29388/stopped%20scrolling%21.png

2011-02-27 13:17:33

#5

Microwave: _; +515|6870|Loughborough Uni / Leeds, UK

PrivateVendetta wrote:
Always title.
I hate having loads of different categories when searching for all songs by a certain artist on my iPod.

This was my thought when I initially adopted the title option, I am having doubts though

2011-02-27 13:18:39

#6

presidentsheep: Back to the Fuhrer; +208|6176|Places 'n such

Artist sounds more right to me, looks right to but if you have an ipod it has to go in the song part or you end up with a massive mess.

I'd type my pc specs out all fancy again but teh mods would remove it. Again.

2011-02-27 13:19:05

#7

Winston_Churchill: Bazinga!; +521|6953|Toronto | Canada

Yeah, its song title. Else your artist/album divisions will be all messed up

2011-02-27 13:19:25

#8

Poseidon: Fudgepack DeQueef; +3,253|6752|Long Island, New York

Title. Makes my library easier to scroll through on my iPhone.

2011-02-27 13:20:51

#9

UnkleRukus: That Guy; +236|5251|Massachusetts, USA

Those "artists" suck btw.

If the women don't find ya handsome. They should at least find ya handy.

2011-02-27 13:20:55

#10

PrivateVendetta: I DEMAND XMAS THEME; +704|6406|Roma

To put it clearer, if i'm searching for that Eminem song, I won't want to look for it under lil-wayne, and I has to be grouped with Eminem otherwise it fucks me off if I want to shuffle all Eminem songs but it won't use the ones with featured artists.
Unless I search for all songs with the word Eminem associated.. but I never do that.

Last edited by PrivateVendetta (2011-02-27 13:21:10)

2011-02-27 13:26:23

#11

mtb0minime: minimember; +2,418|6869

I always put it in the song title. Makes it easier when sorting or filtering by artists, and keep the file structure organized. Also good that I don't have to mark things as compilations when it's really the same artist who happened to have a few people sing on some tracks.

2011-02-27 13:27:21

#12

Gooners: Wiki Contributor; +2,700|6847

Artist - Title (Feat. Artist)

2011-02-27 13:27:24

#13

Sisco: grandmaster league revivalist; +493|6558

I place it with the artist, always. Hasn´t let me down yet. I search for specific songs mostly though, so there isn´t much confusion giong on.

2011-02-27 13:28:50

#14

liquidat0r: wtf.; +2,223|6842|UK

100% of my library is

"Song Title (feat. Artist 2)" - Artist 1

The lowercase "f", the ".", and the brackets are all important.

2011-02-27 13:30:55

#15

Microwave: _; +515|6870|Loughborough Uni / Leeds, UK

I use Ft. no brackets.

I use brackets for remixes.

2011-02-27 13:32:09

#16

presidentsheep: Back to the Fuhrer; +208|6176|Places 'n such

I worked out how to make compilation albums on itunes once... Then everything was sorta fine. But then it changed and I haven't worked out how to do it since, have only got one song on here since my hdd failed anyway.

I'd type my pc specs out all fancy again but teh mods would remove it. Again.

2011-02-27 13:32:22

#17

Gooners: Wiki Contributor; +2,700|6847

brackets look cleaner

2011-02-27 13:33:58

#18

Uzique: dasein.; +2,865|6685

Microwave wrote:
I use Ft. no brackets.

I use brackets for remixes.

a r b i t r a r y

_{libertarian benefit collector - anti-academic super-intellectual}. _{http://mixlr.com/the-little-phrase/}

2011-02-27 13:37:44

#19

Microwave: _; +515|6870|Loughborough Uni / Leeds, UK

Yes..?

2011-02-27 13:43:35

#20

mtb0minime: minimember; +2,418|6869

How about when Artist 1 "presents" Artist 2?

"Artist 1 pres. Artist 2" ?
"Artist 1 Presents Artist 2" ?
just plain old "Artist 2" ?

2011-02-27 14:26:14

#21

Zimmer: Un Moderador; +1,688|6971|Scotland

Neither.

With ID3v2 tags I put in Album Artist as the overall artist, and then I put the "feat Whoever" in the Artist tag. That way my Zune shows me one artist for the full album, but multiple artists for a single song when it's playing.

2011-02-27 14:49:30

#22

Bevo: Nah; +718|6735|Austin, Texas

Song title, otherwise when I scroll through artists I'd get Artist1, Artist1 ft. Artist2, Artist1 ft. Artist3, Artist1 ft Artist4, etc..

Zimm's way would probably be best case, but I cba, and I dont even know if my iphone would sort that correctly

/shrug

2011-02-27 14:51:48

#23

Zimmer: Un Moderador; +1,688|6971|Scotland

Bevo wrote:
Song title, otherwise when I scroll through artists I'd get Artist1, Artist1 ft. Artist2, Artist1 ft. Artist3, Artist1 ft Artist4, etc..

Zimm's way would probably be best case, but I cba, and I dont even know if my iphone would sort that correctly

/shrug

Pretty easy with the app Tag&Rename tbh.

It's brilliant for compilations like Warp20 or Dark Was The Night where it's various artists. I put "Various Artists" as Album Artist and then the individual artists as Artist. Works a treat.

2011-02-27 14:53:54

#24

Uzique: dasein.; +2,865|6685

move2music

_{libertarian benefit collector - anti-academic super-intellectual}. _{http://mixlr.com/the-little-phrase/}

Artist	44%	44% - 8
Song	55%	55% - 10
Total: 18

BF2S Forums Music Formatting Question

Poll

PrivateVendetta wrote:

Microwave wrote:

Bevo wrote:

Board footer