Poll

Would we be better off with no Religion

Yes53%53% - 35
No33%33% - 22
Dont Care3%3% - 2
Prepare to face Jihad -.-10%10% - 7
Total: 66
Rosse_modest
Member
+76|7004|Antwerp, Flanders

Spark wrote:

If you say 'yes', then where will people get their system of morals from? What will they believe in? Science? I don't think so.
That is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard.

People don't need religion to have a good system of morals (religion often even results in extremely warped morals), and why do they HAVE to believe through religion? Why can't they believe in humanity itself?
wannabe_tank_whore
Member
+5|7005

pokerplaya wrote:

isnt money the root of all evil so they say
no, the *love* of money is the root of all kinds of evil
wannabe_tank_whore
Member
+5|7005

XanKrieger wrote:

Why is it it takes Religion to make good people do evil things? Would the world be better off without any form of it as it causes such extremists that ignore basic humanity and commit hideous crimes aginest other people, the war in Iraq and the "terrorists" are a clear example of what a destructive attitude Religion can cause, Discuss...
"Terrorists" is quoted because they don't exist?  Explain how the war in Iraq is "evil".
wannabe_tank_whore
Member
+5|7005

XanKrieger wrote:

Well if ya think about it religion dictates what is good and what is evil so it in itself creates evil and beliefs that lead to extremists
This is coming from someone who thinks of himself as a 'good' person.  Name some of the 'good' you have done.
wannabe_tank_whore
Member
+5|7005

Agent_Dung_Bomb wrote:

Erwin_Rommel188 wrote:

People would find new ways ways to justify killing each other without religion.  Nazi Germany and Communist Russia were both Atheist Organizations yet they both managed to massacre large amounts of people.
Such as that may be, wars and death under the guise of religion have accounted for more death and destruction than all other reasons combined.  While having no religion wouldn't stop it all, it would go a long way to reducing the bulk of it.
Please post numbers/statistics.

Stalin alone killed close to 28 million.  Hope you have some good sources.
wannabe_tank_whore
Member
+5|7005

Marconius wrote:

Organized religion is terrible and should be done away with.  It's way too easy for corruption and exploitation to spread within them, and they get extremely dangerous when politics mix with them.  I.e., the Islamic rage at the moment, Priests and reverends telling their "flock" how to vote and showing political swing videos, using peoples' faith as a control instrument.

Forcing morality, guilt, and shame on their followers all the while taking money from their pockets.  More harm than good has been created or urged on by organized religion, and more and more people are being told what to believe in and what to think, causing them to not be able to (critically nor practically) think for themselves.

People should be allowed to believe in anything they want to believe as in a Freethought society, as long as they do not force it upon others.  RAmen.
Corruption was there first.  Man just brought it to religion.

Schools are doing a good job on telling people what to think.  For example, college vs. high school.  My eyes were opened when i got to college vs. the force fed $hit at high school.  And dont forget about 1972 text books in 1995 classrooms.

Last edited by wannabe_tank_whore (2006-02-09 13:25:40)

wannabe_tank_whore
Member
+5|7005

atlvolunteer wrote:

The desire for power is the root of all evil.  Religion just makes it easier.  It is a lot easier for some power-hungry dumbass to get people to follow him if he is a religious leader.
Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, and Luis Farakhan to name a few.  They hide under the guise of religion to promote their hate.
wannabe_tank_whore
Member
+5|7005

MephistoJade wrote:

Cougar wrote:

Yeah If You Wanna Go To Hell And Burn For All Eternity You Sinner!!
Wow....been protesting outside any military funerals lately? 

Seriously, that is the best example of this thread...EVER.

http://aolsvc.news.aol.com/news/article … 0000000001

Bastards, all of them. 

I'd repeat: Extremism should be eradicated.  if it takes shutting down the major religions to do it? let me fire the first shots.  I'd consider it an honor.
Wow.  You just pissed all over the Constitution.  Our founding fathers would be ashamed.
Vilham
Say wat!?
+580|6994|UK
All the ppl saying politics is just as bad arent realy thinking. At least with politics you have a choice and can change ur mind, with most religions its beat into u from a early age and therefore you dont doubt the things that preachers of that religion say. Religion is used as a control method, its far better than cameras coz it changes ppls minds into how you want them to act. I.e the ten commandments, they could have been writen differently and ppl wouldnt question that. Not many new religions that people truely believe have evolved in the past 500 years, kinda matches the age of science. Ppl wont believe that God spoke to someone and told them that people should follow a set of rules, if u did say that u would get sent to the luny bin.

PS. The majority of deaths in WW2 were civilian deaths and alot of them were due to religion, eg the fact that Jews were Jews, Hitler used that against them if they hadnt been Jews they would have had a much better chance of survival. OFcourse if there were no Jews Hitler would have found some kind of scapegoats.
bobislost
Member
+3|6882|uk
evil people do evil things and good people do good things, but it takes religion to make a good person do evil things
Vilham
Say wat!?
+580|6994|UK

wannabe_tank_whore wrote:

Vilham wrote:

PS. The majority of deaths in WW2 were civilian deaths and alot of them were due to religion, eg the fact that Jews were Jews, Hitler used that against them if they hadnt been Jews they would have had a much better chance of survival. OFcourse if there were no Jews Hitler would have found some kind of scapegoats.
Ok... source please.
Um the fact that all history books state that only something like 2 million soldiers died and like 10s of millions of civilians died....

Or if u were talking bout the eg. Its well know that Hilter used the Jews as a blame for Germany's poor economy.
Vilham
Say wat!?
+580|6994|UK

wannabe_tank_whore wrote:

"were civilian deaths and alot of them were due to religion"

Source that says civilian deaths were mostly due to religion.
k cant give source, for that coz i dont have a specific book name here, but i have read alot on WW2 and most historians agree that the majority of civilian deaths were due to the religion of the person.

just got a quote.

'The Jews of Europe were the main victims of the Holocaust in what the Nazis called the "Final Solution of the Jewish Question". The commonly used figure for the number of Jewish victims is six million, so much so that the phrase "six million" is now almost universally interpreted as referring to the Jewish victims of the Holocaust, though mainstream estimates by historians of the exact number range from five million to seven million.'

just like to point out that if they hadnt been 'Jews' they wouldnt have nessaceraly died.

'About 220,000 Sinti and Roma were killed in the Holocaust (some estimates are as high as 800,000), between a quarter to a half of the European population. Other groups deemed "racially inferior" or "undesirable", Soviet military prisoners of war including Russians and other Slavs, Poles, the mentally or physically disabled, homosexuals, Jehovah's Witnesses, Communists and political dissidents and criminals, were also persecuted and killed. Many scholars do not include the Nazi persecution of all of these groups in the definition of the Holocaust, with some scholars limiting the Holocaust to the genocide of the Jews; some to genocide of the Jews, Roma, and disabled; and some to all groups targeted by Nazi racism.[2] Taking all these other groups into account, however, the total death toll rises considerably, estimates generally place the total number of Holocaust victims at 9 to 11 million, though some estimates have been as high as 26 million.[3]'

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties

just some opinions on religion here...

'This group of models holds that religion is a social construction, rather than referring to actual supernatural phenomena, that is, phenomena beyond the natural world that we measure using the scientific method. Some of these models view religion as nonetheless having or having had a mostly positive effect on society, the individual, and civilization itself, and others view it as having or having had a mostly injurious or destructive effect. Many of these views have their origins in the field of the sociology of religion.'

ill get more.

Last edited by Vilham (2006-02-09 13:49:36)

wannabe_tank_whore
Member
+5|7005
Vilham, I deleted my posts.  I misinterpreted your post.
Vilham
Say wat!?
+580|6994|UK

wannabe_tank_whore wrote:

Vilham, I deleted my posts.  I misinterpreted your post.
np
MephistoJade
Member
+0|6992|USA/England

wannabe_tank_whore wrote:

MephistoJade wrote:

Cougar wrote:

Yeah If You Wanna Go To Hell And Burn For All Eternity You Sinner!!
Wow....been protesting outside any military funerals lately? 

Seriously, that is the best example of this thread...EVER.

http://aolsvc.news.aol.com/news/article … 0000000001

Bastards, all of them. 

I'd repeat: Extremism should be eradicated.  if it takes shutting down the major religions to do it? let me fire the first shots.  I'd consider it an honor.
Wow.  You just pissed all over the Constitution.  Our founding fathers would be ashamed.
Pissed on the constitution, did I?  Interesting comment, though I'd tend to disagree.  I also personally doubt that our druidic founding fathers, Jefferson is a lovely example (he burned bibles, as a matter of fact.) would agree with me about these morons. 

Further, I didn't say that people shouldn't be allowed to express their views.  I said extremists, such as those, should be killed.  If expressing an opinion is pissing on the constitution, you need to learn how to read.  Amendment one, which covers their ability to assemble, also provides for my right to say to anyone I care to that they should be killed.

Further, I said that IF the religions needed to be shut down to end extremism, THEN I'd be happy to do it- again, free speech.  I didn't say that people couldn't believe whatever they wanted, that's fine by me- I would just deny them the resources of an organized, funded church.  Thus, freedom of Religion is not imposed upon.

Pissing on the constitution is giving churches special status in which they don't have to pay taxes, or in some cases, get government dollars.  Pissing on the constitution is saying god bless america at the end of a politcal speech. 

Cheers.
XanKrieger
iLurk
+60|6886|South West England

wannabe_tank_whore wrote:

XanKrieger wrote:

Well if ya think about it religion dictates what is good and what is evil so it in itself creates evil and beliefs that lead to extremists
This is coming from someone who thinks of himself as a 'good' person.  Name some of the 'good' you have done.
I never said i was a good person but that doesnt make me evil
El pistolero7
Member
+0|6863
The root of all evil, is at the beginning of ur thought . the religion is just a tool.
So the religion isnt bad , its the ppl getting it wrong.
Do u think lots of education will help u to be good. Think again..
So the roots are very important , and religion have been thousands of year before u came to earth
So do u think this ppl were plain stupid... dont think material things make u intelligent.
And the world today everybody wants to be rich,
What future we have
Beefy
Member
+0|6871
religion isnt bad
but when religion and politics goes together then its bad
El pistolero7
Member
+0|6863

Beefy wrote:

religion isnt bad
but when religion and politics goes together then its bad
Of course ,we got good examples of that combination. But its the individuals getting it wrong,the ppl with power,
and then the stupid Masses follow them, PPl just dont get it, The greatest message of the bible , koran,
Hindu, konfuism, buddism,  Indian believes is LOVE..
This sounds very hippiesh, potheaded,  but its the truth...
When, Us was attacked at 9/11,  the only thing in mind for us military was revenge,, for the love of their country.....
And revenge is a sin,,sadly... u lower urself to the other guys level ...
If a human being cant control those feelings, all hell break loose.....
thats why religion is a way of living,, Some will understand some won´t
Now u might argue what religion is the best.. and sadly some religions have some faults,
U can get to know God without have been in any religion,, But  remember  ,believes been here since the beginning of time, and it knows a lots of thruh,
U all in this forum, how many years have u been living in this earth, 10 ,20 ,30,
And u allready know about Life.........
Agent_Dung_Bomb
Member
+302|6964|Salt Lake City

El pistolero7 wrote:

Beefy wrote:

religion isnt bad
but when religion and politics goes together then its bad
Of course ,we got good examples of that combination. But its the individuals getting it wrong,the ppl with power,
and then the stupid Masses follow them, PPl just dont get it, The greatest message of the bible , koran,
Hindu, konfuism, buddism,  Indian believes is LOVE..
This sounds very hippiesh, potheaded,  but its the truth...
When, Us was attacked at 9/11,  the only thing in mind for us military was revenge,, for the love of their country.....
And revenge is a sin,,sadly... u lower urself to the other guys level ...
If a human being cant control those feelings, all hell break loose.....
thats why religion is a way of living,, Some will understand some won´t
Now u might argue what religion is the best.. and sadly some religions have some faults,
U can get to know God without have been in any religion,, But  remember  ,believes been here since the beginning of time, and it knows a lots of thruh,
U all in this forum, how many years have u been living in this earth, 10 ,20 ,30,
And u allready know about Life.........
Love huh?  I think you better go back and read the Old Testament.  God was one mean SOB in that section.  It's kind of funny how religious people pick and choose the sections of the Bible, or whatever text they read, to support their point of view, and totally ignore the rest.

The fact is that God does not exist.  Do I believe that when you die you just snuff out and that's it? No.  While our bodies are organic, the rest of what makes us human is energy, and energy cannot be destroyed, it can only be transformed into another form.  I believe we are part of something bigger, but something we just don't yet understand, but God as some all powerful parent figure is just the imagination of the primitive human mind trying to assign a value to something it can't yet understand, and to deal with the fact that mortality is something none of us can escape.

Religion's time is done and should be done away with.  When people start treating each other with dignity, compassion, and respect simply because they are a human being, then and only then will the human race have a chance to survive.  As long as religion exists our future is murky at best.
pokerplaya
want to go heads up?
+11|6962|cairns australia

wannabe_tank_whore wrote:

pokerplaya wrote:

isnt money the root of all evil so they say
no, the *love* of money is the root of all kinds of evil
i had been drinking and was being facetious(pink floyd any1?)money isnt the root of evil because evil can exist in poverty.ignorance and intolerance (not religon)are the true roots of evil.
El pistolero7
Member
+0|6863
[
Agent bomb


I respect ur opinion,,,
And u said it, dignity compassion, respect..  = LOVE
Ant the old testament , If god was that bad:  why do u think he was bad?
The humans in that era, according to bible were Very very BAD....
And u all know, that there are unwritten laws in this planet, if U do something wrong,
U get Twice or more back, And Sure i think God can Punish U..if u break these rules,
But u never know  the Lords ways,,,,
these rules i believe, are here to learn u something and keep u outta trouble
But ur free to do whatever u like,
Some learn the HARD way and some go trough life without Tragedies
If u believe in the energy stuff: and also wiping out religion:
What does that tell u about being bad in this planet, U may do whatever like, and dont give a damn
about what happens after death..
So all the rightious ppl alive today why should they keep living rightious?, whats the point?
If a guy steal my bycicle, i dont call the police, i hunt the guy down ,and Thaibox his ass
but with these " rules", I try to understand and look at the hole perspective, then i let GOD or the divine rules
to take care of it ,
Thing happens without no reason...
[SSG]Hjultomten
Member
+1|6883|Örebro, Sweden
I just have to post this.....
Proven by modern mathematics! This will be short and sweet, but none the less, very enlightning.

First, we assume that all girls take time and money.

Girls = Time x Money

Furthermore, we take the statement, "Time is money", and we get:

Time = Money

Girls = Money x Money

Girls = Money²

Moreover, the statement, "Money is the root of all evil" means that:

Evil = root(money)

Girls = root(Evil²)

which reduces to...

Girls = Evil

And so we have mathematical proof of what the root of evil is!
Take that woman!
El pistolero7
Member
+0|6863
Hjultomten

u should seek to the advanced matemathics courses, or NASA, very interesting, lol
Den var bra , trodde jag var enda svensken härinne
lol
RAIMIUS
You with the face!
+244|6943|US
Most religions preach love.  So, I believe that it is the corrupt leaders of various faiths are responsible for the idiotic acts done in the name of faith.  Look at the Crusades, Jihads, Medival Popes, Pat Robertson, etc.  Religion is the victom of human greed and lust for power, as is politics and many other things.  I think that we are better off WITH religion, because it gives society a starting line.  Morality is defined by religion (it does differ a little bit between religions, but generally agrees in most areas).


Side note:  Berserk_Vampire, give it a rest.  I am tired of hearing about America's evils.  I don't care whether you like McDonald's or not.  You get off topic and simply try to insult people who are having a decent conversation.  It is immature and annoying.  Go off to a Complain section or start acting serious.

Last edited by RAIMIUS (2006-03-01 14:31:20)

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2024 Jeff Minard