BF2s Video Game Awards

2007-12-28 21:10:45

#1

Poseidon: Fudgepack DeQueef; +3,253|6800|Long Island, New York

Well, it was mentioned, but nobody really got started on it. I have an entire setup I'd like to put in the polls section of Everything Else (or here) and let people vote on it. I'm willling to run it the way FFLink13 has the user battle setup, with each topic getting it's own poll.

To get started, I need to know some nominees for games. I'll put 30-35 games total in and they'll be broken into 15 topics for best ____.

Post your top 5 favorite games of the year and I'll tally the vote and break them down into different topics.

Topics will be:

Best Game of the Year
Best PC Game of the Year
Best Console Game of the Year
Best Military Game
Best Soundtrack
Most re-playable
Best Multiplayer
Best Voice Acting (Male)
Best Voice Acting (Female)
Best First Person Shooter
Best Graphics
Most frustrating game
Most groundbreaking game/enhanced technology
Most realistic game
Most intense game

Keep these in mind while voting.

IN ADDITION: DO NOT COUNT THE ORANGE BOX AS ONE GAME. ALL OF THE GAMES WILL BE CONSIDERED SEPERATE. Also, these are games of 2007. Do not add HL2, BF2, HL2 Ep 1, etc into your choices.

Nominations will end January 2nd, 10 PM EST. I'll have the specific topics put into different threads when voting comes.

Here's mine, just so you're not confused about the extra tallies...

CoD4
TF2
Rock Band
Crysis
Bioshock

Tally:

Game	Tally
Call of Duty 4	30
Uncharted: Drake's Fortune	2
Team Fortress 2	19
World in Conflict	13
Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock	8
Rock Band	1
Crysis	15
Bioshock	7
Portal	17
Super Mario Galaxy	5
Company of Heroes: Opposing Fronts	2
Command and Conquer 3	5
Half Life 2: Episode 2	3
Mass Effect	4
Halo 3	10
Assassin's Creed	5
Ace Combat 6	1
Football Manager 2008	1
Supreme Commander	1
Final Fantasy XII	1
Super Paper Mario	1
Soldier of Fortune: Payback	1
Timeshift	1
DiRT	1
Forza 2 Motorsport	1
Fear Files	1
Unreal Tournament 3	1

Current Leaders:

Call of Duty 4 with 30
Team Fortress 2 with 19
Portal with 18
Crysis with 15
World in Conflict with 13

Last edited by Poseidon (2008-01-02 14:26:37)

2007-12-28 21:24:16

#2

Hurricane: Banned; +1,153|6893|Washington, DC

Call of Duty 4
Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
Team Fortress 2
World in Conflict
Guitar Hero III

2007-12-28 21:28:09

#3

cowami: OY, BITCHTITS!; +1,106|6552|Noo Yawk, Noo Yawk

WiC
CoD4

EDIT: Throw in GHIII as well.

Last edited by cowami (2007-12-28 21:28:24)

2007-12-28 21:30:51

#4

Flaming_Maniac: prince of insufficient light; +2,490|6969|67.222.138.85

TF2
Portal
CoD4
Mario Galaxy
CoH:OF

2007-12-28 21:32:55

#5

Poseidon: Fudgepack DeQueef; +3,253|6800|Long Island, New York

Tallies updated from this post up.

2007-12-28 21:34:40

#6

Flaming_Maniac: prince of insufficient light; +2,490|6969|67.222.138.85

I'd suggest a table.

2007-12-29 05:24:34

#7

belZe: Member; +23|7097

Team Fortress 2
Portal
Call of Duty 4
Crysis
World in Conflict

2007-12-29 06:00:47

#8

Spearhead: Gulf coast redneck hippy; +731|6952|Tampa Bay Florida

So wait... hows this going to work again?

There are like 15 different games that could fit into those categories... asking everyones top 5 and then dishing them out to fill up categories isnt going to work too well...

Best soundtrack? Halo 3.
Best military shooter? CoD4.
Best console game? Best voice acting? Most groundbreaking? Mass Effect.

2007-12-29 06:04:35

#9

Snake: Missing, Presumed Dead; +1,046|6828|England

Only played 3 games released this year.

HL2:Ep2
TF2
C&C 3

2007-12-29 06:06:30

#10

rdx-fx: ...; +955|6854

CoD4
TF2

2007-12-29 06:55:52

#11

Poseidon: Fudgepack DeQueef; +3,253|6800|Long Island, New York

Spearhead wrote:
So wait... hows this going to work again?

There are like 15 different games that could fit into those categories... asking everyones top 5 and then dishing them out to fill up categories isnt going to work too well...

Best soundtrack? Halo 3.
Best military shooter? CoD4.
Best console game? Best voice acting? Most groundbreaking? Mass Effect.

I'm going to break them down, but suggestions to which game goes to which topic helps a lot.

The tally is to figure out which games get nominated for game of the year.

Last edited by Poseidon (2007-12-29 07:00:38)

2007-12-29 07:28:14

#12

SamTheMan:D: Banned; +856|6237|England

TF2

Everything else in 07 sucks

2007-12-29 07:34:02

#13

shadowcell_01: How 'bout dem Cowboys?; +45|6807|Flower Mound, TX

put me for wic, ghIII, and cod4

2007-12-29 08:02:54

#14

kptk92: u; +972|6671|tc_london

CoD4, TF2, Halo 3, Portal, Ace Combat 6

2007-12-29 08:09:24

#15

Ryan: Member; +1,230|7106|Alberta, Canada

I'm gunna put in some votes for CoD4, Crysis (just because of the stunning graphics), WiC, Halo 3, and TF2. I haven't played TF2, but it looks fun.

Last edited by Ryan (2007-12-29 08:18:45)

2007-12-29 08:15:13

#16

Winston_Churchill: Bazinga!; +521|7001|Toronto | Canada

Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock
Crysis
Bioshock
Super Mario Galaxy
Command and Conquer 3

2007-12-29 08:23:30

#17

icecold2510: Member; +31|6556

CoD4
WiC
GHIII
Assassins Creed
I can't think of another good one that I've played.

2007-12-29 09:29:00

#18

Poseidon: Fudgepack DeQueef; +3,253|6800|Long Island, New York

Tallies updated from this post and above.

2007-12-29 09:40:07

#19

Doctor Strangelove: Real Battlefield Veterinarian.; +1,758|6731

CnC3
Portal
TF2

2007-12-29 10:02:54

#20

Pvt.Kosak: Member; +125|6849

Why don't you get everyone to pick 5 nomanitons and then the most popular are put into a vote.

I choose Football Manager 2008
Call Of Duty 4
Crysis
CnC3
WIC

2007-12-29 10:05:31

#21

Bertster7: Confused Pothead; +1,101|6844|SE London

Crysis was outstanding. Bioshock was great. COD4 is pretty good.

2007-12-29 10:05:32

#22

Poseidon: Fudgepack DeQueef; +3,253|6800|Long Island, New York

Pvt.Kosak wrote:
Why don't you get everyone to pick 5 nomanitons and then the most popular are put into a vote.

I choose Football Manager 2008
Call Of Duty 4
Crysis
CnC3
WIC

That's what I'm doing. :S

Posts updated from this post and above.

2007-12-29 10:08:39

#23

sergeriver: Cowboy from Hell; +1,928|7020|Argentina

Fail. Orange Box should count as one game, since the 5 games come in one box, and all the major sites and magazines voted it as one game.

So my vote is:

1-Orange Box (sorry, but it counts as one game, you don't split Mario Party into 40 games)
2-Cod4
3-Crysis
4-Bioshock
5-World in Conflict

Last edited by sergeriver (2007-12-29 10:17:28)

2007-12-29 10:08:46

#24

Pvt.Kosak: Member; +125|6849

Oh.

2007-12-29 10:21:10

#25

Poseidon: Fudgepack DeQueef; +3,253|6800|Long Island, New York

sergeriver wrote:
Fail. Orange Box should count as one game, since the 5 games come in one box, and all the major sites and magazines voted it as one game.

So my vote is:

1-Orange Box (sorry, but it counts as one game, you don't split Mario Party into 40 games)
2-Cod4
3-Crysis
4-Bioshock
5-World in Conflict

But it's 5 games in one. Exactly. Mario Party is different, you can't buy those games separately.

Half Life 2 and Half Life 2 Episode 1 were all separate. TOB is basically just a bundle. You could have loved Portal but hate TF2, making it odd to choose TOB as the best game of the year.

And in addition, GameInformer did have TOB as one game but in the game of the year voting, their staff would also pick Portal or Ep 2.

Last edited by Poseidon (2007-12-29 10:23:05)

BF2S Forums BF2s Video Game Awards

Spearhead wrote:

Pvt.Kosak wrote:

sergeriver wrote:

Board footer