Jay wrote:
My point was that if people pay for services they don't necessarily use on the off chance they really need them... well that sounds just like private insurance to me. The difference here being doctor pay is allocated more efficiently by need. Do your rural doctors make the same pay as your city doctors? Ours don't because the market sets the price, not some distant bureaucrat. Your system is different from ours, not better nor worse, just different. I know that non-uniformity makes you uncomfortable, you're just gonna have to fight back your innate engineers desire for symmetry.
People pay for services they don't use all the time, I doubt I use as much as 1% of the states roads, I haven't used the services of the Police, Fire or Ambulance, I don't use the cycle tracks, jogging tracks or the skateboard park - why should I pay for these things then?
I am reasonably confident that I will eventually become sick and die, or could suffer some temporary calamity in the meantime, if or when it happens I don't really want to be reading through the fine print of contracts and legal cases to figure out why I'm not getting the treatment I need and thought I had lined up, or why I'm now in a pit of never receiving healthcare again.
Your arguments are selfish and anti-social, you were happy to take a govt job with cushy benefits when it suited you, now you want to minimise your taxes, when your circumstances change you'll have no hesitation in holding your hand out for govt benefits again, and find a new way to rationalise what you've decided you want.
Our system
is different, we spend a much lower percentage of GDP on healthcare and get much better results. With the profit motive and lawyers largely removed things flow a lot better.
I am glad that my taxes go into efficient healthcare instead of a bloated, greedy and inefficient military though. That would be annoying.
Rural doctors make much more than city doctors. Doctors don't want to live in the country, the govt wants people to live and work in the country as it provides a big net benefit to GDP and exports so they pay doctors over the odds to service those people.
Long term forward planning, instead of endless stupid short-termism and selfishness and every single thing - except the handouts the 'fiscal conservatives' demand for themselves and their friends - driven by the mania of the immediate profit, is what makes for a good country and an efficient economy.
Last edited by Dilbert_X (2013-10-01 02:38:15)