Poll

Greenie_Beazinie "Rednecks, poor people, hotheads join the military"

He is Correct37%37% - 17
He is Incorrect62%62% - 28
Total: 45
Horseman 77
Banned
+160|7054
Greenie_Beazinie Says " Rednecks, poor people and hotheads join the military. "

I think he may have been kidding, If not I would like to know where he is from and what he based this on,

       I am sure in some countries this applies but not in my experience.
I am under the opinion he doesn't know what a " Redneck " is and probably never had one.
It teaches you respect and humility at the least. I don't see these traits as evedent in his posts.
Most people that use the word Haven't a clue What it Really Means and it is a useful way to sort out the Unaware amongst us. Like " Champing at the bit "  or " The Whole Nine Yards* " or " Bit in his teeth " and " Ducks in a Row ". You have to have Been there, at least once, to understand the refrence in its true context.

I think I have come across this guy before, he's up there with
 
Sgt.Gene,  Marconiuos and kinerio.

I suspect The " Whole Nine Yards " is all he needs. Press  Press  Press
Sh1fty2k5
MacSwedish
+113|6927|Sweden
I guess it's true in a way
Marconius
One-eyed Wonder Mod
+368|6911|San Francisco
Here you go Horseman:
2004 Military Recruitment Data

Greenie is quite correct in his statement.  When you are living in an impoverished area, and have no support/get no direction coming out of high school, plus have no money to move out on your own or go to college (plus fail to be granted Federal or State funds/scholarships), there really is no other choice...
Horseman 77
Banned
+160|7054
So it sounds like a good deal then. Plus the GI bill.

You found this post pretty qwick lol. your becoming famous or imfamous. oh well.

" Loved, hated but never forgotten ! "
CrazyCobra
Member
+0|6946
i would have to agree with that survey... when i was at boot camp (navy) i as a white person was a minority...   it seemed the minorities where the majorities at boot...

  this was late summer 05
WilhelmSissener
Banned
+557|6950|Oslo, Norway
well from personal experience, i come from the norwegian lower-upper calss and i plan on joining the air-force.
atlvolunteer
PKMMMMMMMMMM
+27|6989|Atlanta, GA USA
There are actually two definitions for redneck.  From Websters:
1 sometimes disparaging : a white member of the Southern rural laboring class
2 often disparaging : a person whose behavior and opinions are similar to those attributed to rednecks

The first basically means white country boy and came about because the person would get a red neck from working in the sun all day.  The second has become synonymous with bigot.  Most people nowadays only use the second definition.
Rathji
Member
+1|6900
Nothing wrong with  good redneck, I consider myself one by the second defintion and I certianly am not a bigot. unless....

Someone with more time than me want to post a defintion of bigot? Us rednecks don't understand words that big
Kaosdad
Whisky Tango Foxtrot?
+201|6896|Broadlands, VA
Sadly - **in general** the US enlisted ranks are minorities & kids who only got a GED (or not even that).
TehSeraphim
Thread Ender
+58|6941|New Hampshire
You HAVE TO HAVE a GED or high school diploma to join the military - no exceptions (I Believe).  As for his statement, it is completely true.  Hotheads are aggressive, and military life fosters aggression.  Poor people join for cash, and rednecks are usually hotheads, or are raised in a patriotic sense along with hunting, etc., which plays a role on influencing them to join the military.

This statement is most true about the poor, however.  Most see the military as a way to make money when they have few options open to them.  This is why the Army focuses it's recruiting efforts in poorer areas of cities and states etc.,  rather than the upper class areas where people who have money lose a huge incentive to join the military.
Berserk_Vampire
Banned
+7|6905
Why do they need any education to join the army specially the U.S Army (Ok son its like this you point this at the bad guy look threw here and press down on this and bang hes dead dont mind killing women or children either)
2ndLt.Tucker
If you can read this, your already dead
+33|6900|Stillwater, Ok
Have you ever tried to site in an artillery piece or watched to see how it is done.  You need to be able to calculate the trajectory along with the wind to zero in on the target.  This requires math at atleast a high school level.  Avionics in the Air Force requires alot of calculations on computers and what not to make sure circuts don't overload.  The military requires alot of math in certain areas and therefore you can't just take anyone.  However there are some jobs where you could do this.  Besides it would be horrible for the military to have a bunch of gun totin' unschooled morons in combat.

Last edited by 2ndLt.Tucker (2006-02-01 18:41:13)

-=|BW|=-Hollow_Moon
Member
+5|6972
Who would have thought that american soldiers required education or intelligence to join the army? Especialy with all the incidents with friendly fire during the most recent middle east conflict.
atlvolunteer
PKMMMMMMMMMM
+27|6989|Atlanta, GA USA
I must point out one thing: a lot of people join the military to take advantage of the GI Bill.  One of my roommates in college did this.  It worked out really well for him for the most part.  He got a good (for a college student) check in the mail every month, so he could concentrate on school and didn't have to work or anything.  Plus, he didn't have a ton of student loans to pay off like I did(do).  Occasionally they forgot to send his check, but other than that...
And this guy wasn't from a poor family or stupid.  He now has a MS in Mechanical Engineering.
2ndLt.Tucker
If you can read this, your already dead
+33|6900|Stillwater, Ok

atlvolunteer wrote:

I must point out one thing: a lot of people join the military to take advantage of the GI Bill.  One of my roommates in college did this.  It worked out really well for him for the most part.  He got a good (for a college student) check in the mail every month, so he could concentrate on school and didn't have to work or anything.  Plus, he didn't have a ton of student loans to pay off like I did(do).  Occasionally they forgot to send his check, but other than that...
And this guy wasn't from a poor family or stupid.  He now has a MS in Mechanical Engineering.
That the very same thing that I am doing.  They pay for all my college tuition, $200 for the drill check, $300 for the GIBILL, and another $400 for my GIBill Kicker. On top of this i get 2500 dollars in student loans payed off a year for up to 20,000 dollars.  So it is an excellent way to have all your school payed for and not work at the same time.  Along with this you usually get military discounts off cell phone bills, car insurance etc.  It's not a bad life.  You just have to accept the fact that you may miss a couple semesters for deployments.  I missed 1 already and may have to miss another one before i finish my degree.
Gunny_Prixxon
Member
+0|6929|atlanta
If you want to make ignorant statements, don't forget "criminals and dead beat dads" to that statement
Giant_Squid500
Member
+5|6889|U.S.A.
I unfortunatly live in the South right now, im from Chicago though so I hate it down here. And I can tell you from first hand experience that a Redneck is basically anyone from the South, especially Alabama and Mississippi, and  Louisiana. Any joke made about the South on Family Guy or any other show is 100% true.

I would say a lot of poor people and stuff do join the military. Basically because they can't afford to go to college or have no family and no where else to go. I mean hell, the military gives you cloths, food, shelter, the only bad part is you have to risk your neck every now and then.
wileyford
Member
+5|6925
I do find the question interesting, in the context that "I have walked a mile in those shoes".

I have come from a blue collar working class family.  My father had a factory job that paid enough to allow my mother to raise three sons at home as a full time parent ( a real job as I have found out when I became a parent).  I came from the far south suburbs of Chicago, just East of Joliet Illinois.  I don't often care for labels and generalizations but I'll use middle class. 

Shortly after turning 17 I enlisted into the US Army using the delayed entry program, and after turning 18 shipped.  I opted for the Army, because at the time for a three year active duty enlistment offered the most for college money.  I had scored high enough on the ASVAB test to land any job that I wanted but chose to become a 11B, light infantry (travel light freeze at night), and then attend the airborne school.  No had asked me to do it, in fact my parents were not really happy with it as my father had served in Vietnam.  But they respected my wishes and supported me.

After serving the three year initial active enlistment, I opted out and went into the Army Reserve as a Drill Sergeant Canidate.  After serving two years in the Reserves, I transfered to the Illinois Army National Guard and served an additional 8 years and left as a light infantry platoon sergeant, Sergeant First Class.  I opted out because at the time my commitment to the Guard began to conflict with raising a family and starting a new career.  I was at the time getting ready to get my packet together for Officer Canidate School as I had completed the college requirements.  Because guess what, I wanted to be a light infantry platoon leader.

I listened to Pink Floyd, AC DC, etc, but now I listen to country western.  I guess I became a redneck later on.  I didn't miss any meals had a new car, but we didn't have all the money that we needed.  So I guess I was poor.  I was a piss fire and vinegaer young man, knew a lot and would certainly let you know that.  So I guess I was hot head.

But my time in the service as a ground pounder taught me many invaluable lessons.
Respect.  I may disagree with someone but I will always respect their opinion and beliefs.
Loyalty.  When someone needs help, help them.  Never leave someone behind.
Teamwork.  You win together, you lose together.  It's not about the individual, it's about the team.
Humility.  Definately Horsman 77, but with humility comes comapassion.

The requirement for the military is:
Army HS Diploma or GED
Air Force HS Diploma
Marines HS Diploma
Navy HS Diploma
This may be different geographicaly but that's what it is in the Chicago land area.

Aggression is bred into the program of an infantryman.  I would certainly not feel confident if I looked right and left and realized I was going in the shit with a group of indecisive unsure green horns that couldn't fluff a pillow.  War, despite technological advantage, is still a messy dirty affair and at the end of the day it's the combat arms holding/ taking the ground that will determine who writes the history books folks.  There is no substitute for it.  The hothead aggresives usually mellow out, like myself, and those that don't will find themselves in trouble for being knuckleheads.  Military justice is draconian to say the least.  The Constitutional Rights that are bestowed upon the civilians is not bestowed under the Uniform Code of Military Conduct.  Been there and got in trouble, got the shirt and didn't like it.  I personally have recieved military justice and metted out the same.  It is not fun.  The level of aggressiveness during training is not more than that of a pro football, soccer, rugby team during pratice and game time.  Hotheaded aggressiveness off duty or at the wrong time is certainly not condoned or accepted.

Kaosdad008 at one time your statement was true.  During Vietnam the military took what they could get.  But upon my entry into the Army in the 80s, I can only speak for the Army here, those individuals that fit that description were fifteen to twenty year veterans.  The Army had instituted a program to allow those individuals to attend classes to recieve their GED.  Upon my leaving the C Company everyone had at least a HS Diploma or GED.

Crazy Cobra i attended boot at Ft. Benning Georgia, deep South USA.  The Company comprised about an even mix of minorities African Americans, Hispanics, a couple of Phillipinoes, and caucasions.

Beserk_Vampire the reason you need the "educated" person is as 2LT. Tucker stated.  Have you ever called for indirect fire support, or Naval gunfire support, or close air support, or calculated your location (an unknown point) using a map and terrain features.  I have.  It requires algebra, and geometry at the least.  Without throwing in variables of moving targets aerial burst rounds and adverse weather conditions at the firing platform and the target area.  When I was taught call for fire, indirect fire support 4.2" mortar and above, you didn't have unlimited ammo.  You were expected to put the "Fire For Effect" command in by the third ranging round, and minus flight time, two minutes of radio comms while reading a map and observing artillery impact and target reaction/ movement and adjusting off of the ranging rounds.

Friendly fire happens.  To borrow one of Murphy's Laws, friendly fire isn't friendly.  It is a result of many factors occuring at any one time, to again use a generalized phrase, the fog of war.  I'll leave that topic for a later discussion.

I'll stop rambling now, but thought I'd give you the insider from a redneck, poor, hothead.

As a parting thought, I am honored to have served in the US military with the thousands of other soldiers, sailors, and marines.  We may not have not wanted to go where we were sent.  We may not have agreed with why we were there.  We are not politicians, we did not make or implement US policy other that to vote during elections.  But we did what we did for the person to our left and right.

My two cents.

Last edited by wileyford (2006-02-01 22:09:47)

pokerplaya
want to go heads up?
+11|6951|cairns australia
you know if your a redneck if..................you have at least two car bodies in your front yard.................you have an engine hanging from a tree etc.
wileyford
Member
+5|6925
Love it pokerplaya...
When you play country music backwards your wife comes back, your truck runs, and your dog didn't die.
Giant_Squid500
Member
+5|6889|U.S.A.

wileyford wrote:

The Constitutional Rights that are bestowed upon the civilians is not bestowed under the Uniform Code of Military Conduct.
Hmm...are you basically saying the people that join the military give up there Constitutional rights in order to defend ours [the civilians].  I mean thats kind of how I always saw it. And says to me that people need to stop bitching about there kids being in Iraq, they joined the military. The military teaches you to kill, get over it.
Sorry, I just started rambling there.
Horseman 77
Banned
+160|7054
The little cock rat just seems like a loud mouth pussy who wouldn't say shit to anyone face to face.
They always pick a safe place to insult and mouth off about the people who protect them.
Whatever you Were or wherever you came from once you have the balls to join you have more honor than that piece of shit will ever have. That's my point.

Its just a guess but my guesses are usually pretty good.
wileyford
Member
+5|6925
No problem, I'm not upset with what he said.  Heck I paid in sweat and blood to let Giant_Squid500 say that it's all good.  I respect that is his opinion.  I never said anything about anyone "bitching" about their kid being deployed.

But since it was brought up, as a parent, no matter how old your child is, they will always be your child.  They may be six foot two and two hundred and twenty pounds but that big guy is somebodies child.  Any parent worth their wieght in salt will always worry about their child.  When a parent percieves their child may be going into harms way, however that might be, they worry.  When parents worry they bitch complain etc that's what a parent does.

And yes the military teaches you to kill.  All services teach some form of basic rifle marksmanship at least to the familiarity level for all trainees.  That's why they're there.  All Military Occupational Skills are designed to either engage enemy combatants/ units, or to support those elements that are engaging enemy combatants/ units.   

My two cents.

Last edited by wileyford (2006-02-01 23:58:25)

2ndLt.Tucker
If you can read this, your already dead
+33|6900|Stillwater, Ok

Giant_Squid500 wrote:

wileyford wrote:

The Constitutional Rights that are bestowed upon the civilians is not bestowed under the Uniform Code of Military Conduct.
Hmm...are you basically saying the people that join the military give up there Constitutional rights in order to defend ours [the civilians].  I mean thats kind of how I always saw it. And says to me that people need to stop bitching about there kids being in Iraq, they joined the military. The military teaches you to kill, get over it.
Sorry, I just started rambling there.
Yes under the UCMJ in wartime service members give up their rights.  Even in peacetime we  give up certain rights that others can still have.  We have to watch what we say politically and actions that we might do.  Our life of privacy is very little....hell my commander knows when i get a speeding ticket, then i have to tell him why.  All your finances are kept track of, if we overstep a saying where it may be...."Bush is a dumbass i can't stand him." then that in itself can get a soldier court martialed for going against a superior.  We don't go under the same laws that you all do.  We can get in trouble for missing a belt loop. Having out hair too long, tatoos no approved by our commanders...the list goes on.
Greenie_Beazinie
Aussie Outlaw
+8|7031
Why dont you love me Horseman? I'm so sad...

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2024 Jeff Minard